Occupy the Internet
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
Do ideals exist?
Do ideals exist?

What are they? Where do they come from? Do they exist or are they dreams? Are they nothing more than a human mind wanting something he can't have? What inspired The French Revolution? Did Robespierre live and act based on an ideal?

Ideals are figments of our imaginations. They are a collective will and desire for something to be that isn't there. Robespierre began his career in law, he refused a position as judge when he was young because he didn't want to bestow the verdict of death. How then, just a few years later, could he condemn thousands of people to their deaths for an ideal, for a fanciful definition of his nation of France?

Death is the only result of ideals. Perfection doesn't exist and yet so much blood has been shed in its name. So much blood has yet to be shed in its name. It makes me sad to see the word ideal thrown around with a gusto of self-importance. "I live by my ideals!" Robespierre had no ideals. He rose to the top and became the very thing that he once abhorred. Ideals are ironic by nature. They require a constant pursuit of perfection and philosophical living, so much to the point that someone who follows an ideal is likely to lie to a friend in order to protect it. But by lying to a friend he must be breaking any attempt at an ideal friendship.

It's just a word, a word that should be retired. Why can't wars just be given more accurate rhetoric? Money and power are the only words that have any truth in the name of a fight. If ideal has any place in history, it is only with revolution, and wait long enough and those ideals are forgotten. Look at the United States, look how tightly we regard our constitution when the ideal at the time was that the word of law would be very elastic. That it would account for changes that the founding fathers could in no way protect. Right to Bear arms is the one that comes to mind. The constitutional justification doesn't make sense, there is overwhelming evidence that more gun control, in fact very strict gun control, will prevent crime and death. But no, we're left with the same laws because of a lost ideal, one that means nothing as times change.

So be weary when someone uses the word ideal, remember that the word ideal is the greatest ideal of all.
New thoughts a year and a day later. I'm actually somewhat surprised this topic never took off on a site like this, where ideals are traded back and forth unabashedly as if they weren't one of the greatest possessions we can ever call our own. On THINQon we deal, if not exclusively in ideals, than at least disproportionately. On love and art and beauty music politics and religion we talk of how things should be and how things really are and the in-between ways we wish we could achieve if not perfection. Where one post might start with an ideal we quickly get at the matter of things from all those different angles only multitude of contributors can achieve. What once seemed black and white and maybe a little bit gray is transformed into the entire scope of the color wheel by the merest of questions. And in your answer to that one you've thought of another. And now that ideal is so riddled with holes you wonder just how you came by such an extraordinary conviction on the matter to begin with. How silly!

I was talking to a friend who was about to set off on some sort of human rights extravaganza in a far off country. This was hardly the first such journey she'd taken and yet she was nervous. She asked me with almost helpless sincerity about what her life might look like in 15 years. Would she still live by the same ideals she did now? Would she still be saving the world one malnourished child at a time or would she give that all up for some comfortable desk job and happy little life with spinning class every Tuesday and Wednesday morning? How do we know what runs us tomorrow will be the same gasoline we need tomorrow?

That she was worried at all was proof enough for me she'd never give it up. And to this day she is the most altruistic person I've ever met. I can't see that changing ever.

But it has me thinking now that maybe I was wrong in my assessment from a year ago. Maybe ideals do exist and should exist and should be protected. Or else people like my friend could never exist and ideals would just sink and drown in a world of uncaring. This is not to say that ideals can't shift and change as we slip and slide through all that life hoses at us. Just look at the difference a year has made from that post to this?

But how can we protect our ideals? How do we know they exist and how can we make sure they never go away? All I can think to do is dissect them into their most natural forms, into simple statements of fact: Maybe my friend's is Help People or Do Good. And then be stubborn, don't let a conviction slide away because of a handful of thinqon responses, be faithful to yourself as mother, father, brother, and sister and protector to an ideal.

To not let our ideals fall away requires a degree of stubborn affirmation that only the bravest and the stupidest of us can afford.
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: August 17, 2010 at 12:12 AM
Number of posts: 2
Spans 368 days
People participating

  
Searching
No results found.