Occupy the Internet
Study General Glaring at stereotypes
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
Glaring at stereotypes
Whenever I'm at a restaurant/business meeting/university/museum with people who are somehow, who knows why, just waiting for a member of group X to disappoint them in "stereotypical" fashion -- and such a person comes by and obliges -- it always makes me cringe a little more than usual. I feel like it's almost an obligation one has to not allow people any fodder for upholding their narrowminded stereotypes. But is it hopelessly unfair of me to expect anyone to take the reactions of others into account when living their lives?

Maybe you know what I mean:
Girls who whine when math comes up about how they don't understand ANYTHING.
College students from poorer or foreign backgrounds who brag about copying answers from Wikipedia.
Tourists who litter or get drunk in otherwise calm beautiful places.
etc.

I realize that bad behavior knows no ethnic, economic or gender barriers. People are lazy and unscrupulous with depressing regularity. Is it fair of me to be particularly upset in the cases where negative stereotypes are reinforced?
I'm traveling and last night I met a hotel clerk who treated me like a little old lady--and toyed with the little old lady.
I immediately became imperious and as tall as possible (laughable) and made several biting remarks--thereby reinforcing some kind of a  stereotype.
I was disappointed in both of us.Yellowstone-5/18/2010

In response to Linda OReilly
Dear Linda, your little story reminded me of my old teacher, who was extremely fond of old ladies. He is very famous and a star in his field (Krystian Zimerman) and everybody will tell you he is difficult to access and talk to, except old ladies. They were almost the only one who could come and listen to the lessons, or I even remember going to try out my Schumann Fantasy op. 17 at some old lady’s place, who gave me a (biting) comment on my last movement which literally enchanted Krystian Zimerman. I often get asked by young students how they could get in touch with him, and my best answer would be to go with your grandmother and talk to him backstage after the concert.
One problem is that stereotypes exist because many of them contain some truth.  In general, women do like shopping and men like cars.  But I think what you are talking about may have its roots in group identity.  Behaviors that are seen from the outside as negative may have important positive motivations inside the group. 

Take the girls and math.  This is an ongoing problem in the US; I've read about studies that show girls do fine at math, equal to or even better than boys, right up until puberty, after which scores drop or stagnate relative to boys' scores.  It's obviously not a question of ability, I don't think there's anything terribly gender-specific about math, so it must be a social thing.  They want, like all people (adolescents especially, in my opinion), to belong and to be attractive sexually.  And being good at math and science, in general, is seen as unattractive in girls, both by girls and by boys.  Which continues on into adulthood.  Many men, maybe even most, are indeed threatened or turned off by women demonstrably more intelligent than they are, and I think many girls learn early to hide or ignore or denigrate that part of their abilities.  Absolutely tragic, yes, but I am optimistic enough to believe that it is improving.  Not quickly, but steadily.  You don't overturn social pressures like this overnight.

How about frat boys?  Loud, drunk, obnoxious, bullying, chowder-headed, baseball-cap-wearing young men.  But all of those behaviors, the keg stands, the homosexual jokes, the pranks, the bragging, etc. are important bonding behaviors and identifiers for those who are inside.  And they will carry those throughout life, even though they may mellow out with time, being a part of that group will be important and certainly conveys advantages to members of the group, in connections and influence.  Do I want to spend time with them? No.  Am I defending such behaviors?  Also no.  But I think it explains, at least in part, why many people do choose to perpetuate some stereotypes or aspects of stereotypes, even those perceived by others as negative.
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: May 23, 2010 at 1:12 PM
Number of posts: 5
Spans 6 days

  
Searching
No results found.