Occupy the Internet
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
This topic is a continuation of:

Etgar Keret - A conversation with Etgar Keret

Imagination and Technology
It has been speculated that we live in an era of a loss of imagination. Do you agree with that?
I think there is something there, and that you can’t talk on such a thing on such a huge scope. I think that we live in an era which I tend to think over respects technology and pragmatism. Many times when I look at technological development, actually all the time, it is not accompanied by some sort of an emotional or spiritual development. If you go to Neanderthal man then basically he wanted to eat, wanted to have sex, fight, now basically with technology and the internet we can read any book you want in the library, but what we do is we surf porn sites, order take away, and play video games. Not you but most people. There is something in technology that it doesn’t really offer us any kind of new opening for discovering new sides of the self, which I think imagination does. Most of the development is doing the same thing but quicker, and using less battery or energy, but it’s not that people start seeing the world in a different light.

You know, I saw Inception lately, which in a core sense it was like The Matrix revisited. Basically, it was putting in a different envelope, using different technological means, building a different suspense story, and is still one of the more interesting main-stream movies I’ve seen in the last couple of years. It just shows you how unimaginative main stream movies are, that the one which is considered the most groundbreaking is a movie I saw ten years ago. So I really feel, when I’m speaking about popular media, that what you see is adaptations, adaptations of books, comics, video games, you go and see things that you already know. It feels more like a neo-classist era than a romanticist one. It’s more like the idea of executing something that you know better, than a rethinking.
Films Discussed
The Complete Matrix Trilogy [Blu-ray]
Inception (Two-Disc Edition) [Blu-ray]


In response to Etgar Keret
I know what you mean about technology which limits the use of imagination. Before electronic calculators became popular at school, we had to use our brains to work out difficult sums, and this called for imagination in order to estimate a solution. Nowadays, kids just tap out a few keys and bingo, the result is displayed. The gain in speed and efficiency has been paid for by the loss of imagination and intellect.

As to films or popular music being less imaginative or original than in the past, well of course it's true but I don't see what we can do about it because technology is here to stay. The Internet is certainly responsible for a lot of trash or kitsch, just like TV and the movies were in the past few decades. Can we retire to a desert island and cut ourselves off from civilisation? I'm glad, in any case, that when I was a child in the 60's, I had books , the radio, and some monochrome TV to stimulate my imagination, rather than being bombarded by TV channels and Internet day and night. Of course you can usefully combine technology and imagination as for example in a computerized chess game which is never too tired to challenge you to another match. We just need to know how to say stop and turn it off.

In response to Etgar Keret
Maybe the fact that the same topics appear over and over again says something about human nature rather than technology. Think about philosophers: they've all dealt with pretty much the same questions. Granted, I'm no author, Mr. Keret, but I think every piece of literature deals with different aspects of the same basic human questions and fears -- and that is what keeps books from centuries ago still relevant to the modern reader.

I actually do think that technology helps our imagination. Imagination is based on the world around us. Even your wildest stories have some base in what you know. Maimonides wrote in his introduction to the Ethics of the Fathers that there are things that you can imagine but cannot be, like a metal ship floating in the air. Besides the fact that his impossibility is now practically low-tech, the "impossible" thing he imagined still uses elements from his world. Yes, he combined them in an innovative way, but they are not completely foreign. Metal existed, as did ships, and birds flew in the air. Technology has extended the world around us and added more elements with which we can imagine the innovative.
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: July 23, 2011 at 4:49 PM
Number of posts: 12
Spans 15 days

  
Searching
No results found.