Occupy the Internet
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
Rap Music and its legitimacy
I held my nose above rap music for a long time. I regarded it as a lower form of music. I don't know why, I think it was probably a combination of its negative portrayal in the media at the time as well as a desire of mine to like things that were not mainstream. I listened mostly to classic rock and my dad's music back then. I always remember laughing at the media's onslaught on Eminem and yet looking back I completely accepted their position on him. I always considered him to be "one of those kinds of rappers." But now he is one of my favorites, more than any other rapper Eminem can so perfectly represent the entire spectrum of the human psyche. The anger in his words is so strong sometimes I have to turn him off. And in other songs I'm on the floor laughing.

So how did the media's opinion of him work its magic over me and why do most people still hold their noses over him and other rappers? 

The first rap song I realized I liked was High Fidelity by Jurassic 5.  If I had to put my finger on what I liked about it, I would have to say it was the actual music to it. Jurassic 5 employ a unique combination of samples, classic hip hop beats and DJing, as well as an assortment of surprising instruments. They regularly use flutes, horns, and I think I've heard a xylophone in there. At the same time, in front of the music, the handful of members in the rap group employ creative and socially conscious lyrics. Jurassic 5 is fast paced and their meter/flow is diverse. From their song Break:

We fully capable
Make no mistake if we
BREAK a few rules
Make a few moves
And drop a few jewels
On top of your views
Unstoppable dudes
Using third optical tools
To Rakaa few crews
You gotta confuse
Melodically
Use rap to sonically bruise cats
Harmonies move over
Chemically glued tracks the ripper

After Jurassic 5 I quickly absorbed as much rap music as I could find. I went through Biggie and Nas, Jay Z and Kanye, there's Lil Wayne and A Tribe Called Quest, the Fugees and Outkast, Mos Def and Eminem, Dre and Immortal Technique and so many more. (If you want to try politically conscious rap Immortal Technique has no competition.)

I've found rap to be some of the most eclectic kind of music there is. Inside the one term there are so many variations on subjects, styles, musical influences, and feeling. I find rap to be the sponge of all music. More than other types, rap takes on the styles and influences from the widest variety of sources. I've heard rap with jazz instruments, classical, traditional African, and contemporary electronic.

And yet it hip hop music stays on the margins. It of course tops the billboard charts, but it is shrugged off by serious art considerers as little more than a cultural fad that propagates a materialistic culture. So why does it stay to the side? At this point I feel like it has proven its legitimacy as an art form in that it has existed in one or another for at least 30 years and has yet to stop innovating. Why has the emergence of hip hop in culture resulted in such a strong opposition? But maybe if hip hop were to attain a more universal legitimacy it would lack a direction and a purpose and all innovation would stop.

What does everyone else think about the matter? I'd like to hear from people that don't really listen to rap music. And if anyone is interested I have a long recommendation list for all kinds of rap music.
Hi Robin,

I didn't completely get the (next to) last paragraph. It's true that Rap is not as considered as Jazz, but I'm not sure how would we see the difference in consideration. How do you, me, know if it is highly considered as art or not? It is obviously not considered as high as classical music by the classical music crowd, but I doubt you feel it to be as good as Mozart anyway. It's maybe a bit silly what I'm saying, but I was trying to think how would it look if people considered it more highly?

Maybe there is still a crowd that looks down on it, but you should remember that Rap comes entangled with sex, and people look down at anything entangled with sex (especially at children - they're just so short).

To your list of rappers, I would mention the importance of producers. For example, Timbaland, though also as a singer, and Dr. Dre (which you mention). I liked MC Hammer, though he was ridiculed by my time.
As you like quoting the lyrics of songs, I assume you know Afroman. He's good.
Robin, I would like to follow up on this later as it is now very late night.  Part of the issue with rap music is that it is mostly black and it steps outside of the approved lines of many in the society.  The glorifying of black men with guns reminds too many people in the establishment of the 60's Black Panthers.Rap moved away from a certain respectable wholesomeness of love and courting to a reality that is out there.  It was great when it was uncontrollable but it is now controlled by the wrong persons.  Like in one of Em's albums, the producer is angry that Em has moved away from ho's, bling, and guns, and is instead speaking about deeper societal issues.  Rap started with those issues, the issues of social protest.
By the way, this movement away from social issues isnt new.  Many were upset with Marvin Gaye's "Whats going on"?, and other Motown artists like the Temptations, Stevie Wonder and Edwin Starr who were singing more than love songs.  Today's r&b artists mostly sing superficial songs, guaranteed to entertain, distract but not teach or question.
I personally think that modern rap is the lowest form of music.. 

I have a feeling that perhaps Rap Music would not even exist, were it not for the way that record companies have been re-structured in the last couple of decades.

..certainly not as a the mainstream 'culture' that it is today.

no melody (with all it's intellectual implications)

the hook or most valuable or memorable part is usually stolen through 'sampling'... this MEANS something to kids, phsycologically.

The 'heroes' are preaching street-crime and luxury as one thing

Lyrics are highly unoriginal .....everybody is trying to sing the same things better than the other guy

If it were up to me to interpret the whole thing it seems so well-calculated that it couldn't have happened otherwise.

but maybe it's just an artform... who knows
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: March 29, 2010 at 4:47 PM
Number of posts: 22
Spans 279 days

  
Searching
No results found.