Your home for intelligent conversation on the web
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
The allure of gore?
I am always mystified by the allure of gore and wanted to start a discussion on the topic where people could perhaps enlighten me on its reasons. I'll mention that the origin of this post is Gregory's post, in whether animals have rhythm, where he mentions a case of compulsive gruesomeness. Good friends of mine also mentioned how when they look at news sites on the web they are immediately attracted to items on deformity and monsters.Why is that? I'm personally not attracted by it at all so it is hard for me to say anything myself. The net nonetheless is filled with sites with images of gore, not to mention news sites.
I want to make two distinctions here.
First, I want to distinguish it as being very different from looking at the pain of others, which I understand even less and is very popular nowadays. Susan Sontag wrote an interesting book about it: .
But mentioning this clear distinction I'll ask: It always amazed me when I heard on the radio there was a traffic jam because of an accident - the traffic jam wasn't in the direction where the accident happened, but in the opposite direction and caused by everyone slowing their car a bit in order to look at the accident. (amazing.) Which one of the cases is it?

Second,  I want to distinguish the psychological reasons from the philosophical ones. I could mention how the word monster comes from the origin of "to show" and was used at the beginning as metaphors showing us the will of god and things of the sort. I could mention how the Iliad is filled with extremely gory details, so this is nothing new, but these don't give us any of the psychological reasoning for its allure.
Books Discussed
Regarding the Pain of Others
by Susan Sontag

Most think that the attraction to gore (not Al, that's learned behaviour) is innate.  If we can generalise, perhaps it is a fascination to see the effects of things.  I don't think children pull the wings off flies because they are innately cruel, but because they want to see what happens.  And when that effect is on the body or makes deep incursions into the psyche, it is all the more fascinating. 
It's also fascinating to watch fish swish about, to watch the wings open up on a beetle, and to get the second theme in a symphony. 
Indeed, I think most of what's wrong with the world, and perhaps some of what is good, comes from the interest in having an effect on things.  Lust for power and real cruelty that seems to be exterted without cause can be explained by this principle.  It's guided my understanding of many people's behaviour, and has helped me to gain the necessary detachment from it.
If you like literary references, consider Dostoyevsky's Notes from the Underground, where the narrator's notion of freedom comes very close to this idea.
Books Discussed
Notes from Underground, The Double and Other Stories (B&N Classics)
by Fyodor Dostoevsky

Hi Arthur and Gregory,
Interesting  what you say about how people are interested in effect, which fits well with your example of the animals in your Do animals have rhythm post , but what would you say about freaks in the circus? The bearded lady, people with long fingernails, the giant, and so on. There is nothing having to do with effect there, it seems to me. Maybe one could say it has to do with possibilities - seeing possibilities of bodies, possibilities of what the body could become? Maybe, actually, you could say the effect which is interesting there is the effect on the crowd, the effect of the disfigured body on oneself, which is what people want to feel? Perhaps.
Or maybe, the effect they are interested in is simply being disgusted, like in horror films, feeling scared, horrified?

I must say about myself that though I find the figure of the monster very interesting philosophically, as I am too, as you describe, very interested in effects and hence the effect of the monster on people, I'll admit that myself, I am not at all interested in seeing monsters. Disfiguration, outside of Francis Bacon which I would more describe as a disfuguration of the world than of the person, has very little appeal to me. Why is that then?
    

To summerize: what you describe answers part of the question, but not really the fascination with looking at extremely fat people, circus freaks, and accident injured people. I think feeling the possiblities of the body, and the (horrific) effect of the image on the person looking is also part of the answer (as is the wish to feel one's own body which is so hard for many people nowadays), but not all of it. I think there is much deeper psychology going on here. (or, if not deeper, at least another facet of people's psychology.)
This conversation reminds me of a book I read by Jules Michelet  “The witch”, it’s perhaps not completely related but that was my first association with the subject. In the first part of his book, Michelet paints  a portrait of an era and of a fictitious woman. Through her he explains the phenomenon of how the being of the witch came to life and how for the common populace, they were both the terror and the first provider of help. I won’t go into details, he basically relates the hardships of the people living in the middle ages when Christianity became the ruling religion and there was a rejection of antiquity’s traditions and of nature. He writes on how the creation of little devilish spirits and of witches came as a necessity, a liberation and a gift of life. It gave a possibility to get out of one’s misery and become rich and happy or to perish (as can be seen in all the fairy tales of those times), it gave the people hope and an opportunity to get out of their sad reality. I thought it might be close to what people are looking for today, many  are suffering from boredom, another sort of death, and need to feel  alive and reconnect with nature.
Books Discussed
La Sorcière
by Jules Michelet
Satanism and Witchcraft: The Classic Study of Medieval Superstition
by Jules Michelet

Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: January 21, 2010 at 11:14 PM
Number of posts: 15
Spans 337 days

  
Searching
No results found.