Occupy the Internet
The Living Room Psychology and character The beautiful melancholic
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
The beautiful melancholic
There is the question: how to be happy but is it just as fair to ask how to be sad?

Maybe because it's raining in New York, or maybe because I'm cold and don't have a sweater at hand, but right now I'm thinking about melancholy. Whatever it is, whether it be the deep deep gray skies or else my desire to escape this freezing room and run outside into the rain, the rain that is at least warm like the summer, I don't know, but what I do know is that my musings are not because I am sad. For whatever reasons, my mind, right now, wants to explore the beauty of sadness.

Why do we like sad songs? Why do we like sad stories? Why do sad colors please the eye? It's simple to say that it is because they give the happy ones more meaning, more happiness. A day like today, wet and wetter, makes tomorrow's morning sun shine brighter. A duality like this adds meaning to every layer in between the poles. On a rainy day the facades of skyscrapers draw the attention of the eye in a way that is impossible when the sun shines bright and the blue skies flatter our irises. Beneath the gaze of the melancholic eye, often ignored buildings (and often ignored feelings) become beautiful in their own drab way.

To ignore the beauty of sadness is to ignore the beauty of half of the color wheel, to ignore half of the human experience. Maybe we appreciate rainy days and rainy weeks and maybe months because we know that they are replenishing in us what it means to be human, and that eventually all that stored water will prevent drought and sustain (with meaning) the lush green life of our happiness.

So maybe it is as simple as I said above, that a rainy today makes for a sunnier tomorrow. But how can we distinguish the beautiful melancholic from depression? When we forget what the sun looks like at all?
The beauty and attraction of sadness which you mention, and Arthur mentions in post on beauty, reminds me of a related discussion on Why are we attracted to the devil.
What attracts us to the Macabre, to sadness, to the devil, to gore? These are different attractions, but related. I'm not sure.

As to your question how to separate it from depression, I would say it's a matter of quantity. It's like knowing how long can you stay underwater.
 To say that there is such a thing as the "beautiful melancholic" is to be truly out of touch with reality. Anyone that has suffered immensely does not find melancholic things beautiful. When you have suffered immensely, you focus  hard on bringing joy into your life. Or, you fall into depression. But you don't necessarily find melancholy beautiful.  It is the act of moving through pain and being present, in finding the beauty in the little things, in pushing past the pain...It is there that you are able to appreciate what joy you find in life because you have the depth that pain and suffering carved into you...It is there you find the purity. And there is this bittersweet feeling that comes often with appreciating beauty and goodness, in knowing that it may not last and realizing how fragile this world is. But is not the melancholy of it that is beautiful. To wallow in your pain and find it beautiful shows that you have not lived, that you are just a child with a papercut wishing he could feel what soldiers feel as they are run through with swords. You want to know what it is to truly feel.
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: March 19, 2012 at 11:34 PM
Number of posts: 3
Spans 965 days

  
Searching
No results found.