Hello Ellen,
Jokes in music are
quite current, they are part of the composers’ sense of humor, of their
culture. The composer integrated them to his pieces with the purpose of them
being musical jokes so they are not dependent on the relationship piece-performer
for existence, but you got obviously performers who can perform the joke part
better than others. In the funny composers I would put in general the French:
Satie, Saint-Saëns, Debussy and Ravel. Partly because a musical joke can often
be expressed in a sound effect which is what French music is very interested
in. Saint-Saëns has some very funny parts in his Carnaval des Animaux (I’m
thinking of the Contrabass-Elephant or the two pianists attempting a C major
scale). The Russian neo-classics are full of black humor and ironic jokes. Especially
Prokofiev, there is something funny about the intervals and harmony in his
music.
The Romantic composers
weren’t very strong in their sense of humor, I can’t think of one humoristic
effect by Chopin (I would be happy if any of you found some and share here),
Brahms and Liszt are serious too. The romantic composer who stands out for me
in his sense of humor is Schumann with his play of words-notes and his
different characters (well, Florestan is a very witty character). Again,
Carnaval is a subject where composers can express their sense of humor and
playfulness, Schumann has written two, his op. 9 (over 4 letters A.S.C.H) and
the Viennese Carnaval op. 26. The
lettres dansantes, and coquette from op.9 are funny pieces where he uses for
example the little appogiaturas to create this light and playful effect.
In the classical
period the most humorous composer is in my opinion Haydn. He went into great
lengths in discovering all the possible ways to make a musical joke, from
putting in loud instrumentation right at the parts where he knew his old
ladies’ audience was falling asleep, to protest about the musician’s conditions
in that symphony where they all leave, to other musical effects connected with
harmony, rhythm and structure. There is one last composer I wish to add as
having a good sense of humor, it is Bach. It is never the jokes that one laughs
out loud at, it’s a quiet one, but one can’t avoid recognizing his wit by the
way he uses the same motives in different rhythmical options, creating thus
many word games.