Occupy the Internet
Cinema Room Films The Informant [Theatrical Release] When the good guys become the bad guys
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
When the good guys become the bad guys
The Informant! was really good. Surprising and funny right up to the end. It tells the true story of a high executive Whistle-Blower in the 1990s through a comedic lens. I don't want to spoil the movie for anyone. So I won't. But everything following was extracted from thinking about the movie.

Do you think Caesar could pinpoint the day when he lost sight of Rome? Or did he die still believing he acted out of its best interests? Likewise, can we consider the conspirators heroes? They didn't save the republic. Had they gone about things differently maybe they would have and maybe our world today would look dramatically different. No, they weren't heroes. But they did make history, they made it explode in a shockwave of effect and fireworks. Would Caesar be so prominent today if he hadn't been killed?

Where is this line that blurs good and bad? Is it inevitable that with enough power the good will become that which they abhorred the most?

I think the issue must be with my terminology. Who ever said Caesar was good or bad? As we continuously propagate and move further away from his time we move further away from that distinction. And yet it's the easiest distinction to make. We want to make it that simple. He did good for the human species or he did bad. No matter what he did something. Good or Bad are merely annotations added by others. And I doubt they'll stop.

There is trouble though. Everyone is good. Of the entire population only a small sociopath minority actually act with the intent of doing bad. Most criminals in the jails don't see themselves as bad. It's society who does. Those we term terrorists are acting out of the utmost good in their heads. It's us across an ocean and a mass of land who call them bad. It seems like the idea of good and bad must then be a propaganda tool. It's something we put in our heads to justify our actions. But there is no evidence for actual goodness because it doesn't exist. Morality is not inherent.

By my standards I am a good person. But I created those standards based on me. Of course I am good when I apply that lens. Goodness is something inherited from a long tradition of humans who see themselves with a halo. But what happens when we take off that halo from the mirror? Does that enable us to do the things we shunned before? In some cynical cases maybe. But really, I think understanding ourselves as not perfect human beings allows us to set the standards for morality higher and lets us strive to meet those standards.

Goodness is something we should constantly strive for or else we'll stall and become grandiose. I don't want to be good in life, I want to be better.
Films Discussed
The Informant [Theatrical Release]

I just read this as the movie was mentioned in a discussion on Forgery and fraud. I also loved the movie.

Reading your thoughts they reminded me of the new movies in the Star Wars prequel trilogy which I recently mentioned in post. While in the first trilogy the good and the bad is crystal clear - the good wear white while the bad wear black, the situation is much more complex in the prequel trilogy. Any action that happens you just don't know if it's good or bad as even if it looks good at the moment you know that it's all steps in the path to the dark side taking over. That's what is so interesting about the prequel trilogy, it really puts into question these notions of good and bad assigned to actions and results.
I think this is also part of the reason people don't like the prequels, and some even dislike them. It challenges their black and white world view.

As was mentioned in the We are ruled by madmen discussion, so many good people are constantly being manipulated to act in ways which promote "evil."
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: May 23, 2010 at 3:41 AM
Number of posts: 2
Spans 216 days
People participating

  
Searching
No results found.