Occupy the Internet
Cinema Room Films Midnight in Paris Woody Allens' Midnight in Paris
THINQon is a platform for a more intelligent web. It aims to replace the ruling paradigm of the web – that of sharing and gathering information – with a sharing and achieving of understanding. Instead of the Q&A model it offers an experience. A platform for discovery of ideas, people, and yourself.     Continue >
Woody Allens' Midnight in Paris
Has anyone seen Woody Allen's last film? I've pasted the poster you see all over Paris, as I thought it's interesting to note there the allusion to Van Gogh.








There is a discussion here, where Arthur talks about Van Gogh use of the spins and twirls in his paintings and their connection to the 20th century's loss of direction and invention of cinema. The character of the movie is also lost between worlds, the one he lives in and the one he thinks he would have liked to live in, and these two worlds have this in common- Paris. SPOILER ALERT [I suppose you'd first want to see the movie before going on]

The midnight is the midnight of the fairy-tale where miracles occur and a pumpkin can turn into a carriage (though in the fairy-tale it is the opposite- it turns back into a pumpkin, but that's again the same thing in another direction), and in this time the hero gets to stroll in the world he'd wished to live in- Paris in the twenties. The main character is a writer Gil Pender who is in the process of writing his first novel, and all we know about this novel is its opening phrase- the story takes place in a Nostalgia Shop, where things acquire a different meaning with time. It seemed to me that one could interpret Paris as Woody Allen's Nostalgia Shop, where in every corner you can go to a café or a bistro that entertained the artists he most admires, and at midnight they all come alive and talk to him and are part of his movie. I liked this movie, maybe because of my affection as well to nostalgia shops and to Paris naturally, but I also found that all the characters were so attaching. How he imagined Hemingway's tone of voice and way of talking, or the way Picasso is looking at his mistress...
Films Discussed
Midnight in Paris

I thought it was alright. Nothing special really and pretty lightweight. Enjoyment from all the recognized allusions, but beyond the introduction to the theme of an unachievable romantic past, I didn't take too much away.

I never quite bought Owen Wilson's disillusionment with the romantic past. It came too quickly and with minimal development. I think it's a pretty deep theme though, that the romantic past is impossible except for the person who creates it. 

I can't sit here and invoke the romance of pastoral french poetry because that's not my life. However, were I to find some way of connecting it to my present, to instill it into mundane reality, then some day I'll look back at this moment now and think wow, that really happened to me. 

So what is romance? Why do we so easily fall into Hemingway and Fitzgerald and their worlds? Is it because we know it's fantasy, not entirely different from Tolkien and Lewis? Is it because we're painfully aware that our realities are so far removed from bull fighting and literary salons? 

But we know because of those that came before us that we can make it too. That if they put such truth down on paper solidified, then can't we instill our lives with that same truth? I think romance is only so good as it teaches us how to feel in the moment and to wish too nostalgically for an impossible history is the bastardization of the message, that right now, if you make it so, you are in the romantic present. 

right now i'm up high. city's fogged up like i imagine sleepyhollow is. light's almost gone and people's apartments windows are lit up yellow ambient, mine is too but not everyone's is. My speakers low key, with running keys over buzzy bass. The rain's probably going to start and i'm at my desk with a mug of coffee thinking about this great big arm chair to my right. I graduated this week. Am I content right now? the music is in a chorus of "congratulations, a great big congratulations." 

Is this romantic yet?
I don't think that Owen Wilson is disillusioned by the romantic, or the greatness of the past. It is true that he realizes through Adrianna that the “Golden Times” are subjective and rarely belong to the present, but the realization and choice of not transposing his being into living permanently in the past comes from purely hypochondriac and typical Woody Allen's motives- there is not antibiotics and modern medications.

Here is a nice excerpt of Freud about Golden Times, which is very enlightening as to this movie:

“Remote times have a great attraction- sometimes mysteriously so- for the imagination. As often as mankind is dissatisfied with its present- and that happens often enough- it harks back to the past and hopes at last to win belief in the never forgotten dream of a Golden Age. Probably man stand under the magic spell of his childhood, which a not unbiased memory presents to him as a time of unalloyed bliss. Incomplete and dim memories of the past, which we call tradition, are a great incentive to the artist, for he is free to fill in the gaps in the memories according to the behest of his imagination and to form after his own purpose the image of the time he has undertaken to reproduce.” (Freud, Moses and Monotheism)

 It is interesting that Freud talks about the “magic spell of childhood” and that Woody Allen's golden age is in the twenties- in a way, the childhood of the cinema.
Books Discussed
Moses and Monotheism
by Sigmund Freud


In response to Edna Stern
Hi Edna,
 
Following you is a bit like having access to the education I didn't get.  Thank you.  It struck me that what we forget when we romanticize about the past is the toil and travail that is never evident to us.  It is as if there were no travail in the past, only in the present.  For example, when we look at a painting like Turner's The Fighting 'Temeraire', we indulge in the nostalgia of that moment, not the reality of that age.
 

 
Join the Community
Full Name:
Your Email:
New Password:
I Am:
By registering at THINQon.com, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Discussion info
Latest Post: August 15, 2011 at 3:20 PM
Number of posts: 13
Spans 92 days

  
Searching
No results found.