Our times are very strange-with all the
information that is stored virtually everywhere. I was struck by the
huge gap between this current situation and a description I'm just
reading at the moment in Arendt's “Life of the mind,” where she
describes Plato's objections to the written word, though I will just
add that this passage refers specifically to writing philosophy :
“
For there is no way of putting
these things in words like other things that one can learn. Hence, no
one who possesses the true faculty of thinking (nous), and therefore
knows the weakness of words, will ever risk framing thoughts in
discourse, let alone fix them in so inflexible a from as that of
written letters...”...“There is first the fact that
writing “will implant forgetfulness”; relying on the written
word, men “cease to exercise memory.” There is second the written
word's “majestic silence”; it can neither give account of itself
nor answer questions. Third, it cannot choose whom to address, falls
into wrong hands, and “drifts all over the place”; ill treated
and abused, it is unable to defend itself ; the best one can say for
it is to call it a harmless “pastime,” collecting “a store of
refreshment... against the day 'when oblivious age come' or a
“recreation [indulged in] as others regale themselves with drinking
parties and the like.”
Of course, Plato was the one writing
down Socrates thoughts, and Arendt is writing down her thoughts,
which is what I'm reading- but both are thinking of the relation of
thought and writing.
It is similar in music, listening to
music in one's head is very different from playing it. For example,
when I listen to Chopin's Nocturne op. 37 no. 1, I hear the middle
part as a choral sang by a choir of men. I don't quite get that
effect with the piano, it is difficult to catch that specific color
that one finds in one's head.
It is extreme and might not be directly
connected to the current subject, but I find it nevertheless
interesting to bring here and reflect on. How would we live in a
world where things are
ephemeral? Where everything is stored in the
mind?
I believe one should carefully move and
explore the possibilities between those two extremes and see the
advantages each brings into one's life, and make accordingly a
conscious decision on how to moderate or indulge in one's reliance on
writing and other moderns ways through which technology extends our
writing possibilities (photographs, videos, etc.)
Books Discussed